Gemma Fish + Oyster

Nestled in the vibrant neighborhood of Jacksonville’s Riverside district, Gemma Fish + Oyster offers an elevated American dining experience centered around fresh, artfully prepared seafood. This gem shines brightest with its standout oysters selection, featuring varieties like Royal Miyagi, Wianno, and Savage Blonde that are brilliantly fresh and masterfully shucked to order. Whether you savor them raw or baked in their signature Oysters Rockefeller, each bite is a delicate interplay of briny ocean freshness and rich, buttery indulgence.

The menu at Gemma is both inventive and comforting, with dishes that beckon the senses. The Fish and Chips provide a satisfying crunch paired with flaky fish that practically melts on your tongue, while the Rainbow Trout and Scottish Salmon showcase the kitchen’s flair for perfectly cooked, flaky fish accented by thoughtful sauces. Adventurous eaters can delight in the nuanced flavors of the Steak Tartare or the fragrant Pork Belly Bao Buns. The Crab Dip offers a creamy, savory start that sets a high bar for the meal ahead.

Freshness is echoed in the vibrant and creative cocktail and beverage offerings. The Espresso Martini delivers a bold, smooth burst of flavor that’s energizing yet elegant, complementing the meal flawlessly. For those seeking refreshing alternatives, the Fruitquake mocktail has been praised for its juicy, well-balanced sweetness that pairs beautifully with the lighter fare. The wine list, featuring crisp Chardonnay, Sauvignon Blanc, and an inviting Riesling, caters expertly to seafood pairings and every palate.

Dining at Gemma is as much about ambiance as it is about the food. The space is thoughtfully designed with modern décor, highlighted by striking wall murals and lush hanging foliage that create a romantic and enchanting setting—perfect for date nights or celebratory dinners. The warm, cozy atmosphere is enhanced by attentive and personable service, with many guests noting the staff’s genuine kindness and accommodating nature, ensuring each visit feels special and effortless. Valet parking is also a welcomed convenience, making arrival stress-free.

No meal at Gemma would be complete without sampling one of their decadent desserts. The Fried Apple Bread Pudding is a warm, comforting finish with its perfect balance of spice and sweetness, while the Key Lime Pie with Lime Chantilly offers a tart and creamy contrast that refreshes the palate. For chocolate lovers, the Flourless Chocolate Cake melts luxuriously, leaving a rich yet light impression. Seasonal fruit compote-topped Pavlova and the indulgent Pineapple Rum Cake round out a dessert menu designed to satisfy every sweet craving.

Gemma Fish + Oyster strikes a beautiful balance between upscale dining and approachable comfort. Every dish bursts with layers of flavor, freshness, and artistic flair, making it clear that this is a place where the sea’s bounty is celebrated with passion and precision. Whether you’re relishing the freshest oysters, indulging in perfectly cooked fish, or toasting with a finely crafted cocktail in a cozy, elegant space, Gemma promises a magical seafood dining experience that lingers long after the last bite.